We publish vlog/blog posts with accompanying articles covering a variety of immigration topics. They are classified by the following subjects: News, General, Waivers, Family Based, U-Visa, VAWA, Asylum, EB1/NIW, PERM/I140, EB4, EB5, Visitors (B1/B2/VWP), E2, F1, H1B, L1, and TN Visas. Click on the title on any of the articles to read the full blog post:
Choosing the right employment-based (EB) green card category is one of the most important decisions in the entire immigration process. It affects your timeline, your strategy, your evidence, and in many cases, whether you can self-petition or need employer sponsorship.
A lot of people make the mistake of picking a category based on what sounds “best” (like EB-1A) or what they’ve heard is “fast.” But USCIS doesn’t approve cases based on preference — it approves cases based on whether the facts and evidence match the legal requirements.
This guide breaks down how to choose the right employment-based category in a practical, step-by-step way, with detailed explanations of what USCIS looks for, what evidence matters, and how to avoid common strategy mistakes.
Engineers working on important tech or infrastructure
Researchers and innovators
Entrepreneurs building something with broad benefit
Public health, education, climate, energy, security-related work
NIW is often more realistic than EB-1A for strong professionals who may not yet have “top-of-field acclaim” but can show national value and a credible plan.
🏢 Employer-Sponsored Categories (Job Offer Usually Required)
These are built around a job offer and employer sponsorship.
EB-2 PERM
EB-3 PERM
EB-1B and EB-1C also require an employer (even though they’re EB-1)
If you cannot or do not want to rely on one employer, self-petition is usually the better strategic framework.
Step 3: Identify Which EB Track Matches Your Background
Here’s the simplest way to “map yourself” into categories.
🥇 EB-1 Options: Who They’re For and When They Fit
⭐ EB-1A: Extraordinary Ability
Choose EB-1A if:
You can meet at least 3 of the 10 criteria strongly, and
Your overall evidence shows sustained acclaim and top-of-field standing
Strong EB-1A signals:
Independent media coverage about your work
Major awards or highly selective recognitions
High-level judging of others (peer review, panels, competitions)
Leading/critical roles in distinguished organizations
Original contributions of major significance (with proof others rely on them)
Strong letters from independent experts that explain impact, not praise
Avoid EB-1A if your case relies mostly on:
Internal company praise
Future plans and projections
“I’m a founder so I must qualify”
Weak or repetitive recommendation letters
🎓 EB-1B: Outstanding Professor or Researcher
Choose EB-1B if:
You are in academia/research, and
You have strong research recognition, and
You have a qualifying U.S. employer offering a research/teaching position
EB-1B is often a great option when you:
Have publications and citations
Review for journals
Have awards/memberships
Can prove international recognition in your field
Have a research role at a university or certain qualifying employers
Key note: EB-1B requires employer sponsorship and has specific employer requirements.
🧑💼 EB-1C: Multinational Manager or Executive
Choose EB-1C if:
You worked abroad for a related company for at least one year (in many cases), and
You’re coming to the U.S. to work as a manager/executive for the related entity
This is common for:
Global companies expanding to the U.S.
Managers/executives transferred from overseas branches
People with real managerial authority and organizational charts to prove it
EB-2 Options: When EB-2 Is the Right Fit
EB-2 is a very common category. But the pathway matters.
🧠 EB-2 NIW: Best for Impact + Plan + Credible Evidence
Choose EB-2 NIW if:
You have an advanced degree or exceptional ability, and
Your work has broader U.S. benefit, and
You can explain and document the national importance and your role
NIW cases win when they clearly show:
The problem or need (why it matters)
Your proposed endeavor (what you’ll do)
Your track record (why you can do it)
Evidence that your work impacts more than one employer
NIW cases struggle when they are vague:
“I want to work in the U.S. in my field”
“My field is important”
“I’m skilled so it’s in the national interest”
🧾 EB-2 PERM: Best When Job Requirements Match Your Credentials
Choose EB-2 PERM if:
You have a job offer that requires an advanced degree (or equivalent), and
The employer is willing to complete PERM and sponsor long-term
The PERM-based EB-2 case becomes a “job-based compliance” case:
Recruitment steps must be done correctly
The job requirements must be reasonable
Your qualifications must match the requirements exactly
This can be a great route if you’re in a stable employer relationship and the job truly fits EB-2.
EB-3 Options: When EB-3 Is the Smarter Strategy
EB-3 is often chosen when:
The job requirements don’t reach EB-2 level, or
The beneficiary’s profile doesn’t cleanly match EB-2, or
The employer wants a more straightforward fit based on role/requirements
👷 EB-3 Skilled Worker / Professional
Choose EB-3 if:
The job requires a bachelor’s degree (professional), or
The job requires at least 2 years of training/experience (skilled worker)
EB-3 is not “worse.” It can be the right match when it aligns cleanly with the position and the applicant’s credentials.
Step 4: Look at the Evidence You Actually Have
This step is where strategy becomes real. A category is only as strong as the evidence you can prove today.
📌 If your strongest evidence is recognition and influence
Consider:
EB-1A
EB-1B (if academic + employer)
EB-2 NIW
📌 If your strongest evidence is a job offer + stable employer + matching requirements
Consider:
EB-2 PERM
EB-3 PERM
📌 If you’re a founder or independent professional
Consider:
EB-1A if you have strong top-of-field evidence
EB-2 NIW if you can show national importance + strong plan
Sometimes O-1 as a step before EB categories (not a green card category, but strategy-wise common)
Step 5: Factor in Timing and Practical Risk
Even if multiple categories are possible, you want to choose the one that is:
Most defensible
Least dependent on fragile factors
Best supported by your evidence now
⚠️ Risk Examples
EB-1A filed too early can lead to denial and create a record that must be addressed later.
PERM cases can be derailed by recruitment mistakes or job requirement problems.
NIW can be weakened by a vague proposed endeavor or lack of external proof.
A smart approach is not “highest category,” it’s “most winnable category with strongest evidence.”
Step 6: Watch Out for the Most Common Category-Choice Mistakes
🚫 Choosing EB-1A because it sounds best
EB-1A is powerful, but if your evidence is not at that level, NIW may be the smarter move.
🚫 Picking EB-2 when the job is really EB-3
If the job requirements and credentials don’t match EB-2, forcing it can create avoidable issues.
🚫 Building a founder case around the company instead of the individual
EB-1A is about the founder’s achievements. NIW is about the founder’s endeavor and national importance. Company hype isn’t enough.
🚫 Ignoring the “fit” between job requirements and your experience letters
USCIS and PERM adjudications are detail-heavy. Dates, duties, and consistency matter.
Step 7: Use a Simple Decision Framework
Here’s a practical decision map you can use:
✅ Choose EB-1A if:
You have strong independent recognition
You can meet 3+ criteria with strong documentation
Your overall record shows top-of-field standing
✅ Choose EB-1B if:
You are in research/academia
You have strong research recognition
You have a qualifying U.S. employer offer
✅ Choose EB-1C if:
You are a true manager/executive
You have multinational qualifying history
Your U.S. role matches EB-1C standards
✅ Choose EB-2 NIW if:
Your work has broad U.S. benefit
You can clearly define an endeavor
You can show you’re well-positioned and the waiver makes sense
✅ Choose EB-2 PERM if:
The job requires advanced degree level
Employer will sponsor and do PERM correctly
Your credentials match perfectly
✅ Choose EB-3 PERM if:
Job and credentials fit EB-3 more cleanly
You want a straightforward employer-based strategy
Conclusion: The “Right” Category Is the One You Can Prove
Choosing the right employment-based category is not about picking the highest label. It’s about selecting the category that best matches your facts, your evidence, and your long-term plan.
If your story is centered on personal recognition and impact, self-petition categories like EB-1A or EB-2 NIW may be ideal.
If your story is centered on a job offer and employer sponsorship, PERM-based categories like EB-2 or EB-3 may be the most strategic.
When in doubt, build around your strongest evidence, not your strongest hopes. The goal is a case that USCIS can approve based on clear, documented proof.
